Editor's Note

AI and the Illusion of Photography17

Photograph

J.R. Eyerman

Written by

Marco Savarese, Editor-in-Chief

A packed cinema audience wearing 3-D glasses watches the screen, in a black-and-white photograph by J. R. Eyerman.

“We are intelligent enough to invent AI, stupid enough to need it, and foolish enough not to know whether we’ve done the right thing.”

This line is funny because it’s true. And it becomes even more accurate when applied to photography, a language that, by its very nature, is born from direct confrontation with reality, with time, with error, with limitation.

In photography, artificial intelligence is often presented as a neutral tool, a form of assistance, an acceleration. But photography is not a matter of speed, nor of efficiency. It is a process of observation, of choice, of presence. And every time we delegate part of this process to something that does not look, does not wait, does not take risks, we shift the very meaning of the photographic act.

This is not about nostalgia or resistance to technology. Photography has always been technological. But there is a fundamental difference between a tool that extends the gaze and one that replaces it. When AI begins to decide what to improve, what to remove, what to add, we are no longer working with reality, but with its simulation. And a simulation can be convincing, even beautiful, but it is never neutral.

The risk is not that AI-generated or AI-altered images will be bad. The risk is that they will be too easy, that they will erase conflict, unpredictability, and friction with the real. That they will turn photography into an automatic answer, instead of an open question.

For me, photography remains an act of responsibility toward what is in front of me. Toward the time I live in. Toward what I choose to show, and what I accept not to control. In this sense, the use of AI in photography is not only a technical issue, but an ethical one. It is not about what we can do, but about what we choose to do.

Perhaps yes, we are intelligent enough to invent AI. But the real question is: are we aware enough to know when not to use it?

More notes

Written by Marco Savarese, Editor-in-Chief

More from Eyeshot

Pre-order price ends in — See the releaseShop