Editor's Note
Not Everything That’s Nocturnal Is Noir73
Photograph
Brassaï
Written by
Marco Savarese, Editor-in-Chief

Brassaï and Fred Lyon photographed the night, but not the same night. The problem is that today we often use them to justify any slightly dark photo with a couple of streetlights and a reflection in a shop window, as if turning off the sun were enough to create atmosphere. It doesn’t work that way.
Brassaï wanders through a Paris that doesn’t exist by day. He goes into smoky bars, brothels, crooked alleys, damp courtyards, faces you would never see, or would pretend not to see, in normal light. For him, night is not a nice filter; it’s a way of slipping into another layer of the city, dirtier, more ambiguous, more off-balance. His photographs hold up because the world he inhabits comes first, and only then the aesthetic of darkness.
Lyon does something else in San Francisco. The fog, car headlights, bridges, hills, it looks cinematic, but inside there are always bodies, stories, small movements. It’s a city that could easily turn into a postcard, yet it stays alive because he doesn’t treat it as a decorative backdrop. He isn’t chasing a “noir look”; he’s looking for how the city breathes when artificial lights come on and everything else disappears.
Today, a lot of night photography skips all of this. It’s plastic Brassaï, plastic Lyon. Little lights, reflections, silhouettes against neon, mood in bulk, and no real city underneath, no real people who aren’t reduced to convenient shapes. Darkness becomes a preset, not a choice. If you mentally move those photos into broad daylight and nothing changes, it means the night isn’t serving the work; it’s just makeup.
From the perspective of someone who makes books, this is the simplest and cruelest test: take away the charm of the night: does anything remain? If you remove the “wow” of lights and contrast, is the city still there, are the subjects still there, does the project still breathe? If the answer is no, then you’re not photographing the night. You’re using the night to avoid really looking at what’s inside.










