Editor's Note

What You Can’t Decide180

Photograph

Philip-Lorca diCorcia

Written by

Marco Savarese, Editor-in-Chief

A shirtless young man stands behind a diner counter at dusk beside a jukebox and a burger in a red basket, in a color photograph by Philip-Lorca diCorcia.

Most of a photograph you decide before you shoot. One part, the most important, you never decide. The light, the framing, the distance, the focus point are set in advance, on location or at the table. Who enters the frame, the face they make, the exact instant arrive or they don’t. Confusing the two is the most common mistake.

Between 1999 and 2001 Philip-Lorca diCorcia worked on a street in Times Square. He mounted a flash on a scaffolding, set a camera with a telephoto across the street, marked a faint spot on the ground, and released the shutter when someone who interested him walked over it. Everything controllable he had decided beforehand. The passersby knew nothing. What he could not decide, who would arrive and with what face, is what makes those heads photographs and not stage sets.

The temptation, when you go out, is to push that line forward. You want to govern the encounter, choose the expression, arrange the scene. Every time you decide one thing more, you gain a portrait and lose a photograph. The street gives you nothing if you decide everything. It gives you something only where you leave it open.

Now a machine plans that part too. A recent system builds the entire portrait before the shutter, pose, camera, light, exposure, inside a three-dimensional space, and it works because the constructed portrait lets itself be prepared down to the last gesture. The street does not, and that is not a flaw. As an editor, when I open a portfolio I recognize at once the images decided entirely upstream. They are correct and dead. The ones that kept a margin open still breathe.

Before your next time out, try separating the two lists. What you decide in advance, the light and the position, decide it well and without excuses. What you cannot decide, do not try to. Protect it. A photograph prepared entirely before the shutter remains the illustration of an idea. The one that left a margin is the only one that can still surprise whoever looks, and whoever made it.

More notes

Written by Marco Savarese, Editor-in-Chief

More from Eyeshot

Pre-order price ends in — See the releaseShop