Editor's Note

When Your Work Is Read Against You134

Photograph

Martin Parr

Written by

Marco Savarese, Editor-in-Chief

A packed open-air swimming pool crowded with sunbathers on a hot day, in a color photograph by Martin Parr.

Every now and then I receive a portfolio accompanied by a text longer than the photographs. The photographer explains what they meant, why they chose that subject, what we should understand. I read it, look at the images, and realize, without that text, the photos don’t hold.

In 1986 Martin Parr publishes The Last Resort. He photographs New Brighton, a seaside town near Liverpool, families surrounded by rubbish, children among waste, greasy food, polluted pools. Ring flash, saturated colour, close range. No compositional mercy, no filter. David Lee accuses him of treating the working class as “soft targets,” a bourgeois mocking those worse off than him.

Parr doesn’t defend himself with a manifesto. He takes the same tool and points it at his own class, then at tourists, then at the rich. The method never changes. Who ends up in the frame does. When asked about the criticism, he replies: “I accept that all photography is voyeuristic and exploitative. I live with my own guilt and conscience.” He doesn’t pretend to be innocent. He doesn’t explain. He keeps publishing.

What interests me as an editor is that the New Brighton images didn’t need an explanation. You could read them as contempt or as indictment. You could hate them. You couldn’t call them weak. The ambiguity between class prejudice and social critique couldn’t be resolved by an artist statement. It was resolved, if it was resolved at all, in the body of work.

We already know images should speak for themselves. The point here is different: what happens when someone uses them against you? When the reading is hostile, when your work is turned inside out? If it collapses, the problem isn’t the viewer. If it holds, no accusation can touch it. That’s the test no artist statement can take for you.

More notes

Written by Marco Savarese, Editor-in-Chief

More from Eyeshot

Pre-order price ends in — See the releaseShop